4.11.2023

What Now?


It's gloomy out there on the web. At least it seems to be for people who are interested in photography. I just read that Thom Hogan of Bythom.com is taking a month off. Maarten Heilbron, whose camera reviews on YouTube were always fact-filled, fact-checked and fun to watch has thrown in the towel on making camera reviews; mostly because the major camera makers have stopped spending enough on marketing to even be able to send out review cameras to reviewers. Not as give-aways but as temporary loaners. Maarten's post from a couple of days ago is entitled: "It's Over."  Of course there's the big story about DP Review shutting down as well. 

Many of our favorite bloggers who wrote about photography and cameras seem to have aged out, or run out of steam and inspiration. Topics skew far afield and little nuggets of good, insightful information abut photography have become harder to pan for than gold. 

I find blogging is widely devolving into a cult of personalities in which the writers' life and life stories are given much more emphasis than the topics we originally sought them out for. Yes, it's nice to have well written articles but even better when they are on subjects we're interested in. 

Both Thom and Maarten provided numbers or anecdotal information about the overall decline of the camera markets and, by extension, the world of the profitable practice of photography. From them as well as other sources I think we can agree that at least in the short term the outlook is bleak. Especially when measured by camera sales...

The ever-growing and deeper piercing nail in the coffin for most photographers with a certain tenure in the market is generative A.I. If you think it's kludgy or not ready for prime time you need to step up your research a bit and I think you'll see that, in capable hands, the technology is going to be is devastating for professional photographers. The taking of headshots, product shots, and most lifestyle advertising will vanish as jobs. Or projects. Or sources of income. All that will remain are folks content to sit in front of computer monitors carefully describing what they want the robots to make for them. And, when it comes to commercial work, why not? Clients always seem to know what they want. Their accounting departments are loathe to pay humans for silly stuff like.....art. And making up whole worlds on the fly is a heck of a lot quicker and infinitely cheaper than sending out a human to do their best with reality. Fantasy is much more addictive and hence much more lucrative for advertisers. No cameras or shoe leather required.

I remember watching a movie in the 1960's called, "Jason and the Argonauts." It featured lots of stop frame animation and claymation. Those were primitive visuals and yet the audiences went right along with the action. Now we can drop a computer generated stand-in for Carrie Fisher into a Star Wars movie ("The Last Jedi") and not even be able to tell that the moving image of her character is totally CGI. No suspension of disbelief required. Seamless --- and at thirty frames per second.

We don't have to dislike or renounce photography to grapple with where we are at this point in time. When the gear talk goes away so will community. There is no future in writing about the philosophies of picture taking. Why? Because as much as people profess to want access to such material only a tiny handful will really read it or search for it at all. How do we know? Because the internet has tested that for decades. We love to talk about gear. We are bored talking about aesthetics, or any non-mechanical process. 

I know you're tired of hearing about my fucked up refrigerator and the ongoing saga of corporate incompetence. I know most of you couldn't give a rat's ass about my ability to swim or the happiness I derive from it. And seeing yet another tranche of images from Austin's downtown is just depressing. It's the same for me on other blogs. Snooker? Breathing machines? Vegan-ism as religion? About as interesting to me as the nuances of the competitive flip turn are to you. 

So. What now? Without a ready market camera makers will slow down new product introductions. Eventually Fuji will make sure everyone who takes photographs with a dedicated camera has access to a Fuji X100V and will then probably shut down. Why bother after full saturation?

Some kids will mine the used market for rangefinder, film Leicas for the next few years and walk around in the street shooting with 28mm lenses until the last sources of 35mm film dry up and the labs close down. A few people who lack other talents will doggedly soldier on over at YouTube to make walk-and-talk videos about whatever new cameras or old news comes their way. But everyone is seems to be moving on, ditching photography as we've known it and replacing it with automatic content from their phones. 

Seems like the perfect time to retire. 

Here's my current plan: I'm 90,000+/_  page views away from my content here having generated 30,000,000 page views. That's measured by Blogger and not including stuff you read on an RSS feed. Add in those numbers and it's several times more. But I can only measure what I can measure. When I hit thirty million page views I'll take a big long look at the trend lines and if they are, as I predict, falling off a cliff I'll take note, sign off and leave the web to the last few, standing and producing photography experts.

I figure we're about a month away from the target date. I won't see it as a defeat if I decide that we're done. I'll see it as the turning of a page and my adaptation to human evolution ( or de-evolution). But I will say one thing. Now I understand how newspaper editors, writers and photographers felt as the ground slipped out from under their feet. 

One thing I'm going to do over the next 30 days is to write only about photography, cameras, lights and lenses. I'll try to give the blog a fighting chance at relevance. Wish me luck. 
 

37 comments:

Raymond Charette said...

Good Luck! No sarcasm intended.

Kirk, Photographer/Writer said...

Thanks Raymond, Sad for me because I really like the process of writing about photography as well as the gear. We won't starve. We're not in an existential dilemma it's just one of the those weird shifts in technology/commerce/art that no one likes but the bean counters.

Anonymous said...

Kirk,
My first ever and probably only comment...

I have been following VSL since the days of the Panasonic GH2... it was your photos (and by extension the review of the GH2) that caused me to re-engage in photography as a hobby. I went from a point and shoot to the GH2 and am now using a G9...(Leica is one bridge to far for me...)

So it was your camera and equipment reviews that drew me in over a decade ago, but what keep me as a daily reader was your "tranche of images from Austin's downtown", your talk of your swimming, your meeting up with old friends, your love for your family, your "studio dog", your latest commercial endeavors, your superlative portraits, your enthusiasm for new gear, your travels, your quest for the best coffee, your failing refrigerator, your DIY mastery, the ice storms, your US politics, your "mirror selfies", your auto reviews, your REI fashion reviews, your Texas republicans, your annual physicals, your struggles dealing with aging parents, your red wine, being an executor, your own aging, your Easter Cadbury eggs etc etc... and the fact that it was your blog and you would write it the way YOU wanted.

I can fully appreciate your desire to reevaluate your writings... that is necessary and required...

But I hope that you will NEVER underestimate the comfort and joy that you bring to so many with your photos and life observations.

You are blessed with a unique ability to communicate through your images and writing.

Your willingness to share allows for a true bond with your readers.

For that I will always remain immensely grateful.

Thank you Kirk.

Alfred
Vancouver, BC

Biro said...

This is all depressing to think about, Kirk. But, as a journalist, I know we have to face facts. For selfish reasons, I'm hoping you'll find there's enough interest to continue. But I also realize there's a very good chance that won't be the case.

I'm putting the finishing touches on my updated/renewed photo kit in anticipation of retirement. In some ways that's exciting. But in other ways, I know this may be my final photo kit that will have to last me.

So, good luck and have fun as you continue to blog over the next month or so. But do let us know that how infernal refrigerator saga turns out.

James Weekes said...

I will refer to the work of one of your commenters. As an avid reader of the Lucas Davenport/Virgil Flowers and now Letty Davenport series I can tell you that, aside from the action and plotting, the things 4hat bring me back are all the little personal parts about 5heir lives. That’s what makes us all keep coming back. Keep writing, swimming, walking, and buying new stuff. We love all of it.

TMJ said...

It's always better to decide to leave on a high. And if this is really the final curtain, the story of how Austin has developed around you, warts and all, has been a fascinating one told in seamless prose with memorable images.

ODL Designs said...

Hey Kirk,
Been a while. Thought I would chime in here and offer at least 2 cents worth.

It all depends on why you do it, unlike so many reviewers and commenters are in it for the money and advertising dollars. While your purpose might be more building or maintaining an authority voice through publishing regularly. The reduction in commerce for them, isn't the same as any loss in purpose for you...

It's definitely an odd time, but as I told a major camera company many years ago... they are the temporary benefactors of a market that never wanted to own a camera. The happy snappers. The people the film companies lost, and for a while the camera companies captured. But they were never theirs, and didn't really want what was being peddled to them.

I am not sure AI is quite there. For what it's worth, I have noticed that the more things become artificial, the more people are craving the real. We shouldn't forget this digital age is barely 2 decades old, and for much of that it was nothing to speak about.

Interesting times.
Keep well and keep swimming!

Dick Barbour said...

I've been an amateur photographer for a lot of years... The film days were frustrating in many ways, but we did what we could with what we had. The digital age has been wonderful, and I still enjoy the acts of taking, processing, and sharing photos. I went out this morning in the glorious sunshine with my 5-year-old Lumix G9 and my 6-year-old Sony a6500 and took some landscapes, some flowers, some birds... I've finally gotten around to learning how to use the G9's "Super-high pre-burst" feature which takes about a half-second of photos BEFORE you press the shutter! How cool is that? Now I don't have to rely on my aging reflexes to get that bird taking off from its perch. But I do have to sort through 50-odd shots to find the best one. LOL!
All of which is to say I still get a big kick out of my photography, and I can't see that changing. However, I've also enjoyed reading, discussing, and learning about it in a number of online venues; it seems they are mostly going away and that's a real shame. I hope you see fit to continue the VSL, Kirk, but if you don't I'll understand and know that you're still out there somewhere getting your kicks, too.
Dick

Robert Roaldi said...

Just finished reading an article about how AI may decimate the voice-over actor industry too. It stated that their contracts now often ask that they "... consent to the synthetic generation of their voice, at times without additional pay."

What I'm wondering is if anyone will want to fork over good money to watch/listen to something generated by someone else's computer. The content creators can only hide the fact for so long.

Rob Allen said...

For what it’s worth, I’m here for the swimming, exercise & life stories as much as for the photography.

Interesting writing is interesting and I’ve learned a lot form VSL.

JC said...

You know, some people are just made for work. That's how they live their lives. If you are one of those, you can bullshit forever about what you might do, but you'll probably keep working. If not as a "professional" photographer (headshots, etc.) then as an artist. I'd read your artist blog.

Michael Matthews said...

Like JC, I’d read your artist blog. But I remember the last time you swore off gear forever and decided to devote the blog to the ART of photography only. That lasted about two days. Maybe three. Alfred of Vancouver said it best. His summary of why we keep coming back does a much better job of saying what I’ve tried to say before. We just like to feel as if we’re keeping in touch. Even if the flow is largely one-way. Those who can, write. As for the rest of us…

I think your friend Andy, ATMTX, has come up with a viable alternative if you decide to cut back but not bag it altogether. Post a daily photo with short copy, in a form which arrives as email as well as appearing on a blog site. Then roll out a newsletter…once a month, once a week, whatever…that goes on at length on as many topics as you wish. That approach provides the structure of regular deadlines, but lets you float the publication schedule of the newsletter.

Should you decide to try that, request every blog reader who is interested to send an email with the subject line “I’m in”, with no added text needed. Compile the list over a month or two. Then change gears.

I hope it doesn’t come to that, but it’s an alternative to consider.

Lovin’ that vaguely steampunk view of the future seen up top. Maybe a print?

Anonymous said...

I've been reading this blog since around 2009 or 10, not even sure anymore - the years kinda blend together after a while. I think it was shortly after you started the blog? Whatever, it's been a long time and it's been enjoyable to read, so I hope you keep it going.

By the way, for what it is worth, when Thom Hogan takes a month off his blog, he is usually somewhere in southern Africa (usually Botswana) on a safari (or two). I know only because I was on a couple of his Botswana safari tours about a decade ago. He is offline but still very much involved with photography during that time.

Ken

rgonet said...

Kirk,

I second what Alfred from Vancouver said. He speaks my mind.

Richard

Jim said...

I'm good with reading about your swimming and your broken fridge. It is like listening to a friend who also shares my interest in photography. Never mind the numbers. I will keep 'listening' if you keep writing.

John said...

I think you’re probably right about much of commercial photography, but not about photography as a hobby. We care about TAKING pictures of stuff and people that actually exist. That’s not going to disappear, just like lots of people enjoy fishing even though they can buy fish in the store.

Rene said...

Agree with Alfred above. I've been coming here since around 2012 at least, each and every day. Usually, I read you with/just after my breakfast as I eat late in the morning and it's always a nice way to start the day. I've listened you your advice about gear and couple of times I've bought camera/lenses based on your advice and never been disappointed.

I'm happy to read bout swimming, fridges, the family and everything else. II started out thinking of you as a "Pro" I could learn from and often mentioned you to other photographers as a "guy who knows how to do it right." Now I think of you as a friend I can rely on for a good story, a rant and photography advice.

I hope you stay and I'll miss you if you go, but know you've helped at least one person become a better photographer.

Rene

Joe said...


Well, I read the post to the end and hope that you now set 35,000,000 as the next goal post. I look at only a very few blogs each day, VSL chief among them, and that's for insight about taking meaningful photographs. That beats gear any day.

Roland Tanglao said...

what fellow Vancouverite Alfred said! please keep blogging your amazing stuff as long as you have the energy and enthusiasm to do it!

BTW bythom.com will be back. I believe this just one of thom's twice a year breaks from blogging.

Derek S said...

Page views may be interesting milestones, though nothing more. You have grown a community and while we're all getting older I believe there will always be new interest in this ageing art. What you have created its unique and valued. I think you need to write too. And we readers are thankful to you for providing us with a refreshing oasis in the desert. It is comforting to find good natured banter that chimes with our experience - and it is just as good, if not better, to have our assumptions challenged occasionally. Long live our art and The Visual Science Lab.

Coasting said...

Sad to think you have come to that realisation.I feel you have a community here that enjoys the banter and wise words that you create from your world.Its more than all things photography tis a slice of life.Hang in there and be a lone voice that we all enjoy

Unknown said...

I also agree with Alfred above.
& I am more than fine with coffee, swimming, life's issues (when will GE decide it is cheaper to just replace? I thought that Texas had strong lemon laws?) & photos of Austin.

If I ever make it to Austin again or you make it to Glasgow/Edinburgh I'll buy you a coffee (& maybe tempt you with a pastry).

crsantin said...

I've always enjoyed this space, your writing and your insights. I would be sad to see it go but I do understand. Going out on your own terms is always better. It seems the world is a vastly different place since the Covid pandemic. That moment in our history seems to be some sort of turning point. Things are different now, people are different. I find myself scrambling to make sense of my professional life since things have returned to "normal". For us hobbyists there will be enough good gear on the used market to last us older guys a lifetime. I'm not worried about that. I'll be able to put together a few kits to last me the rest of my days. Maybe your fridge woes will come to a nice conclusion and you'll feel better about the future? LOL. Let us know what you decide.

Robert Roaldi said...

Blogs like this one are our culture's substitute for meeting in the town square after supper to gossip or to join clubs to yak about lens lore or other things. We don't do that kind of communal activity much anymore but we must miss it.

Mike said...

Hey Kirk,

Thank you for all of your effort to keep this blog going. Personally I don't know how you do it. I can maybe come up with a few things to say a few days a week, but your ability to string together well thought out post every day is admirable. I personally can't see you not doing this, and I hope you never step away from the keyboard.

As far as AI decimating professional photography, all I can say is that those of us who do this will adapt, just as we did back in the 80's when stock exploded and corporate and low level advertising work slowly died.

I can't imagine headshots, especially at a high level going away, just maybe AI will do the retouching. Another part of the profession that cannot be replaced by AI is event photography. No replacement for being there. Granted, AI will probably find its way into the editing process, but there's no replacement for being there and finding those moments where you can cut through the chaos and crystalize the spirit of the event in a photograph. At least that's my hope.

Or another, and way darker way to look at this is that AI will find us to be redundant, and we've all see those movies and know how it turns out. So we might as well enjoy what little time we have left before the conflagration, or until we get plugged into the matrix.

Until then, I'll keep making photographs, and I know you will too. And I hope you'll keep writing about it, because I know a lot of us will keep reading.

Take care,
Mike

karmagroovy said...

Don't feel like you owe it to your readers to soldier on. If you wake up a few mornings in a row and feel like writing another blog post is more like work than joy, then that's a good sign that it's time to hang it up.

Yeah, commercial photography is going to be a shadow of itself very soon. Lucky for me hobbiest photography will live on. My Nikon D700 is going to outlive me so no worries there!

Alex Bush said...

Isn't this a bit perverse Kirk? If I keep reading your blog I'm encouraging you to stop writing it. Catch 22?

Alex

Kirk, Photographer/Writer said...

Alex, I think you have it backwards. If you stop reading the blog and others stop reading the blog it will stop. If reader numbers are stable I soldier on.

Anonymous said...

Maybe use comments as an additional measure of the value of your blog, to help you decide when to wrap it up. After reading through the comments on this post, it appears you’ve got a bunch of people who love the blog, and appreciate your efforts here…I certainly do!

Malcolm said...

Several years ago I proof-read a book by a friend of mine, Calum Chace entitled "The AI Singularity" which predicted how industries would change as AI became more prevalent. Nothing happened for a while, but I am starting to see it come true now. And likely it will only accelerate at Moore's Law rates (doubling every 18 months or so).

As for gear I have all the cameras I (as an amateur) will ever need; I stopped buying years ago. I went into a camera store the other day and realised that I simply cannot justify several thousand pounds for a body-only mirrorless Canon. The other day I took my 4MP 1D to the local race track and shot cars for fun. Good enough for my needs.

I even went back to film several years ago, but the prices for colour film especially are crazy now. So once my freezer is depleted I'm not sure what I'll do. Shame, as I enjoy photography.

Thomas Backa said...

I do thoroughly enjoy your writings about any subject. As others have commented, those who can write are destined to write. We others are doomed to just read. You are a writer. I don’t know if there is a cure to that malady other than to write, so if you decide to push the shutter button on this site I’m confident I’ll stumble across your musing somewhere else in the future.

Your blog in the only one I visit daily.

If people don’t like pictures of buildings from Austin, then post more pictures of people? I’ve seen on Instagram that the city streets of Austin are full of very interesting beautiful people.

jiannazzone said...

Kirk, I have enjoyed reading VSL for a long time (I think you were enamored with a Nikon 1, V1 when I started reading) and will be disappointed if it disappears before me. However, you don't owe us readers anything. You do all the work, we get all the pleasure. Keep writing for yourself, not for us.

Anonymous said...

Maybe I'm odd, but I like the act of taking pictures so I don't see that going away.

I only take pictures for myself, and there are better examples of what I've captured already existing on the internet. As a hobbyist, that makes no difference to me. I have that luxury, and for now I can ponder the question of what is "genuine" work, and what is prefab. And, is there a difference and to who?

Beyond that, I don't know, but the phone market has already well kneecapped the camera market so manufacturers are in tough as it is.





Anonymous said...

Bill Gates said that People overestimate the impact of technology in the short run, and underestimate the impact in the long run.

Some "yikes" built into that statement when thinking of AI

Phil Gyford said...

I'm a newcomer - I've only been reading for a few months - but I came, and stayed, for your writing about all the not-photography stuff as well as the photography. Whatever you're writing about, it's a pleasure to read.

Rob said...

G'day Kirk, echoing the positive, supportive and appreciative comments prior. I do like your turn of phrase, and eye for images - aye, even if t'is another palette of Austin!

And while I'm a happy amateur dilettante, I get a bit of a thrill when someone's picture turns out well... like the portraits you share from a different league.

Thanks for all the words, whether of photos, swims, and life.

Anonymous said...

Kirk, I don't comment often here, but I have to say I open your blog almost every day to read your content.
I like your take on gear.
I enjoy the Austin downtown images and they are actually a source of inspiration for me in that they make me willing to walk around my small town in Italy and try to take interesting photos of so familiar environments.
And I also enjoy when you throw in swimming, family stuff, refrigerators, DIY and so.
I'll surely continue to come here every day and hope to find something new to read and enjoy!
Thanks for all the words!