What do you like about the VSL blog?
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
What content is useful for you?
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
Do you like the gear reviews?
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Where do you get your photo information?
That's about it. I'm feeling like the blog is getting stale. It's been a twelve year project and I've written something like 6,000 posts, put up tens of thousands of images, and suffered through 60,000 comments (many good but a ample percentage of well intended but unhappy ones...). I'm not sure what I've been spending my time on still has value. The blog is not and has not been a source of income for me.
I've polled all sorts of clients (the people who do continue to line my pockets) and not a single one of them is a reader of the blog. Most were blissfully unaware of its existence.
I'm in an actual quandary because I know I get emotionally attached to stuff like this even beyond any utility or positive affects. If I were rational I probably would have pulled the plug long ago but, in my defense, I thought people might still want something to read during the pandemic lock-downs.
Let me know as honestly as you'd like....what would you do? And how would you do it?
Kirk
51 comments:
What do you like about the VSL blog?
Running a photo business and gear reviews
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Too many of the same photos/too many repetitions of archival photos. Too much repetitive musing
What content is useful for you?
Running a photo business and gear reviews
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
Not really, but you are a sane voice. I think you just do not need to post everyday. Only post when you actually have something to say.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Do much less work! Only post when you actually have something new (or reasonably new) to say.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
No
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
No
Do you like the gear reviews?
Yes
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No, but there are too many. Sometimes you come over a little smug (you asked us to be honest!)
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Yes
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
I wouldn't expect any warning. It is just a blog!
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
Yes, see above
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Just update it infrequently, if there's something new to say
Where do you get your photo information?
Dpreview, ByThom, B&H, Bambousek, Mike Johnston (he has a similar issue to you IMO), Mirrorless comparisons, Camaralabs, Photonet, Fred Miranda etc etc.
My advice is to not feel compelled to keep your audience. After all, we are not really important to you as you are not earning money from the site. If you keep it up online then I would check in on it once a week. If there's nothing new that's fine. That's what I do with most photo sites.
Chris, Thanks for the feedback. KT
Kirk,
That I got into answering all your topics is probably a meta-commentary on how much I appreciate your commitment to producing VSL.
What do you like about the VSL blog?
That it is about you living your life as a photographer, and not just about photography. I don’t read gear-review blogs. Visiting VSL everyday is like having coffee with a friend. I don’t expect a mono-topical conversation with friends. Friendships form over shared interests, and that opens the door to more shared human experience - which is what helps us grow as individuals.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Not much - and I don’t tend to tell friends what I don’t like, because the relationship matters more than the raw content of a conversation.
What content is useful for you?
I do like your discussions about working with the people who are your creative partners (i.e., the subjects of your photos). It informs my personal ongoing project, which is about capturing people in the most natural way.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I’d be pretty disappointed!
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
If what you write about is what you like to write about - keep it up. The VSL logo could be smaller : -)
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
Not at all. Photography is a creative activity that should be accessible to all, whatever the means or experience. It’s just nice to have expert practitioners sharing their methods, views, frustrations, and successes.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
On many levels, photography is storytelling. Do we, as a species, ever get tired of good stories? Different formats, across the spectrum from oral to 3D immersive, have their strengths and weaknesses in conveying. It’s nice that we can pick the ones that work for us at any given moment. I mostly like photos and books.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Only so far as they inform the way they affect your creative views.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No. It’s who you are. My online “coffee klatch" includes you, Michael Johnston, and Mark Hobbs - you all have a different daily experience that informs what you do with your photography.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
For me, a big attraction.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
A lot.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
Whatever gives you energy. The “old” images are good too. Mixing it up (your blog content) can be a refreshing.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Geez. We couldn’t all afford to move to Austin.
Where do you get your photo information?
See above, plus one “rumor” blog for my camera-brand (Fuji Rumors) - my accession to FOMO. The rest is studying photo books by photographers who are people-focused, Jane Bown, Doisneau, Karsh, Alfred Newman, Peter Bellamy, and all the classics.
John, Thank you very much. I appreciate the feedback. KT
I look at your site regularly, as I find reading about people’s experiences with cameras, etc., keeps up my own interests. I look here and at various forums on dpr to look at photos, see what folks think about their gear, see if problems are being experienced, possibly contribute an opinion sometimes. I have next to zero common interests in your commercial work, video, swimming, or mannequins, but I am a photographer and I read your writing, for the writing and for the photographic fellowship regardless of the subject material. A writer has to write, so keep on with it. I find common ground in worldview. And I sort of commiserate with life in Austin…but, as a native Texan, I frankly find Austin insufferable these days. I don’t mind seeing some repetition in photos posted, but unlike photos posted on dpr, say on the L-mount or micro4/3 forum, yours don’t often contain EXIF data, and sometimes I am curious. Maybe Precision Camera should provide you with all sorts of new cameras and lenses for your review and comment, things you wouldn’t buy for yourself, but given your experience, we might value your opinion. I can’t follow you down the Leica rabbit hole, but your take on the OM1 or Z9 or GH7sii or some new Canon would be interesting. However, there’s only so much sand in the hour glass so I don’t expect to see you on youtube tossing around a new lens, walking around Austin getting coffee and kolaches any time soon. But it would be interesting.
I agree with what others are saying for the most part, but I have always enjoyed most your discussions on how you handle a project be it video, portraits, or audio. I do like reading your blog every morning but I could enjoy it just as much if you posted less often, though I would miss it. Your lifestyle and comments are enjoyable to read and for me a kick in the butt to continue to exercise. Im 78 and in relatively good shape (not according to my wife) but enjoy your approach to life and the problems that are encountered and dealt with. If you go, I will miss you, but I'll always be glad I sort of knew you. As for where or what blogs, websites etc I read, I enjoy byThom, the online photographer, Lightroom tips and tricks, Lenswork online, PetaPixel, occasionally DPreview, The Luminous Landscape (although not as much as when Michael was running it) and other sites that talk about photography and not so much about gear. Thanks for all your efforts over the years, I have been onboard a long time. I sure hope Photography does not become irrelevant! Chappy
Kirk,
You obviously do this blog thing because you want to and/or find it enjoyable. The simple advice would be to continue in that vein.
It's a luxury, really.
If you want a break, take one.
I, for one, do enjoy the rather rambling nature of this place. Nobody is trying to sell me something, and sometimes I even get food-for-thought. That's nice.
Hank
What do you like about the VSL blog?
The writer
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Nothing of note
What content is useful for you?
Lighting, especially for portraiture (I bought your online tutorial a few years ago)
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I would miss it as I learn from it and good blogs create that ‘community of practice’
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Post on specific days only
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
The opposite; in a changing world, an author who recognises and embraces those changes is particularly important
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
Some traditional photography has, the PJ has largely disappeared. But high quality imagery is as valued, by some, as ever.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Excellent, real hands on tests by a pro, couldn’t be better. And I like the video content, especiallythe lighting and audio side.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No they reflect you as a person and present a context for the blog to be positioned within.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Very interesting, although photography isn’t my profession
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
Ten years would be fine, thanks……………
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
That could work, better if rotated between the written blog. You almost do that now.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
An email newsletter, as Ctein does.
Where do you get your photo information?
AP Magazine, Reid reviews,Tom Hogan and you.
Kirk,
Without specifically answering all of your questions: I enjoy your blog as an almost-daily conversation with a friendly, wryly-humorous person who loves photography as much as I do, and who has an interesting life besides. The fact that I live in the Austin area makes it all the more relevant for me. I like all of the off-topic and on-topic subjects with the exception of lighting gear and techniques, which I don't have a need for or interest in. Otherwise, anything goes. I especially enjoy the photos and gear commentary of course, even though your types of photography don't really match up with mine for the most part. Would I be devastated if you stopped doing it? No, of course not, but I would miss a pleasant part of my life. Thanks for doing it all these years, no matter what you decide.
Dick
Kirk, I read you everyday and enjoy most posts. I am interested mainly in your portraiture and your ideas about lights (Hey! where did that post about Powerful LED's go) I am amazed at your stick to it ness, writing everyday and many words. I would be sad if you were to quit, but I would understand, it must take a lot of energy to write so much everyday. But it is obvious you have abundant energy.
I love your portraits. You are my portrait hero.
I better look at that list - I read Tom Hogan, an email newsletter would be nice, I like looking at your photos, but I like what you write - I can deal with swimming stuff - love the gear stuff - yeah, you do not need to post everyday (or do you) - I would miss you if you quit - I like the writer too.
I especially like it when you talk about lighting.
I especially like it when you talk about lighting
I've been a regular reader pretty much since you started - or close to it. I enjoy reading your comments and thoughts - particularly your general content thoughts about photography and posts about your walks around Austin - but at this point reading VSL is a bit like reading the newspaper - it is an enjoyable habit, whatever the coverage. I don't get much out of the video or gear stuff but as I said, it is an enjoyable habit to read what you write - and it doesn't bother me when you go off-topic or rant. And unlike another commenter, I like your general musings.
If you close-up shop, or just eliminate the blog, it'd be like when a favorite bookstore closed - I missed it but life went on. It is not like you're getting paid for it. I think the previous times you quit, B reminded you that you write as much for your own enjoyment as anything else. If that is still the case, just take a few days or weeks off and keep writing. If you no longer get enjoyment out of it, don't.
As to whether photography has become irrelevant. I don't know, though camera companies are fast becoming irrelevant for me. I am happy with my DSLRs and I have lost interest in most of what manufacturers are trying to sell me these days. But that's just me.
Bottom line, as I noted above: I enjoy the blog, the random topics and photos included, and would miss it if you quit. I guess it goes without saying, keep writing as often as you like, and as long as you find it enjoyable, and at least some of us will keep checking it out.
Ken
Kirk,
I don't think I have anything to add to the positive comments above that wouldn't be repetitious. Like many of the others, I look forward to reading you whenever you post and I enjoy most of what you have to say. For selfish reasons, I would be sorry to see you discontinue the VSL blog.
Richard
What do you like about the VSL blog?
Just about all of it. I skip past any bits that I'm not interested in. Also, I like that it is written and that it's not a vlog.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Nothing. I have no expectations.
What content is useful for you?
Almost all of it except the swimming.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I'd miss it the way you miss a regular columnist or novelist who stops writing. For example, I miss not reading new Elmore Leonard novels.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
I don't know, but I could see not publishing as often,
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
Not at all.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
Nope.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Very much.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
I don't swim, don't get water fun at all, but sometimes I even read those.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
That's some of the best content.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
I expect no notice.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
It would not mean much to me. A gallery on any server site would do that job, I don't see how that fits a blog environment.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Keep in touch with whom. Presumably you're already in touch in some way with people that you want to stay in touch with.
Where do you get your photo information?
dpreview for equip feature content, various lens test sites whose names I can't remember, a few m4/3s vloggers, TOP, luminous landscape, a few m4/3s sites, talking to friends, trial and error
Write when you want to or not. Post images you like. Write about whatever interests you. Don't take negative comments so hard. When it stops being fun quit writing.
What do you like about the VSL blog?
Your thoughts on photography, photographs, and the business of photography.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Lately, too much gear talk.
What content is useful for you?
I enjoy most of it, but as far as practical use I value your thoughts on portraiture and business. And sometime the lighting tips.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I'd miss it. It's the last photo blog I follow regularly
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
LOL One thing I thought of a while back is you might from time to time get together with someone in photography or the creative world. maybe once or twice a month. Have lunch or coffee, talk shop or art, and write that up as a blog post. Maybe that wouldn't seem too much like work.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
Nope. If anything we need more solid, sane voices.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
No. If anything, more relevant than ever if you think of all the diverse ways it is used, shared, and expressed these days.
Do you like the gear reviews?
A few now and then can be interesting. Too many and I skip over them.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
Really love them.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Very. Always interesting if not directly useful. I'm about 99% retired from pro photography, but I'm still interested in the business and how it's changing.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
Doesn't matter a lot. If it ends, it ends. But I hope it doesn't. Maybe slow down a bit.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
I think it would lose a lot.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Not sure I know. I do follow your Instagram, but that's not the same thing.
Where do you get your photo information?
I check byThom a few times a week, look at dpReview and a couple of the forums for product news, now and then PetaPixel has something interesting. I like PixImperfect on YouTube for Photoshop ideas, but don't really follow it. That seems like a long list, but really I spend less time and energy on it than I used to. For me VSL is the most consistently interesting of the bunch.
That's my thoughts, for what it's worth
What do you like about the VSL blog? The style of writing, the industry insights, your predictions (you were way ahead of the curve on EVFs), your portraiture, your ever-changing gear and your chats about family and Texas (I was hoping to visit National Instruments in Austin once, but prboably won't get the chance now).
What do you dislike about the VSL blog? Not much
What content is useful for you? Not sure about useful, but definitely enjoyable.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way? It'd be a shame to see it go.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part? Tutorials on taking portraits. Not just lighting but making people feel at ease and getting the best out of them. Tutorials on the basics of all the video jargon: codecs, bitness, colour balance, ...
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant? No, I enjoy your industry insights. You get it more right more times than most 'professional' photo websites.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant? Definitely not, just more democratised.
Do you like the gear reviews? I used to when things were affordable and changing fast. Now everything is so far ahead of what I can make use of, and so expensive, that new gear is not that relevant to me. Also, I'm not that into video, although I still read your posts on it, as they are educational.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.? Nope. It's because of you that I learned to swim properly. I'm still not a strong swimmer by any means, but I'm pleased with my achievement. Thank you :)
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you? Interesting
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog? I suspect you'll just stop one day. You've done it before.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions? There's Instagram for that.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog? Instagram
Where do you get your photo information? You and TOP mostly. But I also read a lot of film photography sites.
Loving the feedback so far. Thanks!
What do you like about the VSL blog?
I like that your honest about what you do and how you do it.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
Nothing really, I have no expectations.
What content is useful for you?
Business, photography, lighting, life lessons.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
Yes, a daily touchstone would be gone
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
I know the blog is primarily about you, your thoughts about things, and your photography. However I wouldn’t mind seeing you talk more about the work of other photographers, those that have inspired you, or perhaps even some that do work that you enjoy and respect. But that would require more work.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
No, never.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
No.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Yes.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Yes.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
I think that is completely up to you.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
So long as the captions continue to speak eloquently, then ok.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
I think keeping in touch at that point should be up to us. If you’re going to discontinue the blog, I assume it’s because you want your time back.
Where do you get your photo information?
Less and less of the information I get from the online community is relevant. Most people who write blogs have never made a living with a camera, or if they did it was long ago and for a very short period of time. There are few like you who have actually supported yourself with your photography. Most bloggers and vloggers are a bunch of pontificating blowhards making all of their money off of ads and affiliate links. You’re the real deal, an honest worker who makes good photographs and is a nice guy to boot.
I missed the original post about tourists and whatnot. I don’t think you should ever retract things like that. If you don’t like the responses you’re getting, just shut off the comments, but let the original article stand. It’s your blog, you get to say whatever you want. If you want, perhaps mark it as an editorial, and if you’ve been misunderstood, perhaps add an addendum.
My suggestion, if you enjoy sharing your thoughts and photos with us, keep it up. If you stop, I’ll miss it. However the decision should be completely up to you.
Thank you for caring, and being polite enough to ask our opinion. If you were a New Yorker, you’d just say F**K YOU and do what you want.
MikePeters, Your last line brought a big smile to my face. Funny stuff. Thanks! KT
1 I like the writing, the humor and the photo insights
2 Not much I don't like.
3 All of the photo content helps in one way or another. The swimming is inspirational. Makes me go to the gym when I don't want to.
4 It would take a pleasure away from me in the morning. It would save me many dollars. My camera collection is a combination of VSL and TOP
5 Start walking in different places.
6. Hardly. Your continued workload is proof.
7. Maybe photography in general, but good photography...never.
8. In general, no but yours are reviews working reviews and very insightful.
9. No. I swam in high school and hated it, I'm a hockey player, usually, in the winter. But it is nice to see the continued movement in something you love.
10. Not useful, but always interesting.
11. 5 years
12. Nice but not as good as VSL.
13. Photo post cards
14.All over the place, mostly the web.
Kirk: the blog is excellent as it is and I'm really grateful! Please do not change anything!
What do you like about the VSL blog? INTERESTING VIEWS ON PHOTOGRAPHY AND LIFE
What do you dislike about the VSL blog? I ENJOY THE BLOG
What content is useful for you? DISCUSION ON CAMERAS, LENS, ETC - DISCUSSIONS ON USING STUFF IN REAL LIFE
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way? I READ ALL THE ARTICLES SO YES
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant? NOT AT ALL
Do you think photography has become irrelevant? NIT AT ALL ALTHOUGH AI WILL BE OF INTEREST IN THE FUTURE OF MANY FORMS OF ART
Do you like the gear reviews? YES
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.? LIFESTYLE JUST ADDS PERSONALITY
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you? YES
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog? ANYTHING OVER 6 YEARS WOULD BE FINE
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions? NOT AS INTERESTING
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog? ON THE BLOG
Where do you get your photo information? MANY SOURCES ON THE WEB AS WELL AS MY LOCAL STORE AND A WEEKLY BREAKFAST WITH FELLOW PHOTOGRPAHERS
Honestly I read and probably would read anything you decided to talk about in a day. I don't considered your blog photography only, more like whats life like for Kirk.
So I enjoy your full detailed on the job posts. I have been reading since the start, when you were using an Olympus E3 camera. Those posts woke me up to how much I would want to do photography as a full time job.
I also enjoy your writing style. When your blog said members only one morning, I was about to try and figure out how to get added. But then it vanished, but then came back.
So maybe I was expecting a post like this.
I think you could use this to clear your mind, or get things out.
Photography seems to be cooling off. Mostly get my news from Petapixel, dpreview, rumor sites and Imaging Resource.
I also will randomly Google search for specific lenses tested on specific cameras, like Gfx reviews.
Kirk I think you know where I stand on all of this. I enjoy your writing, your stories, commentary on life and photos. I especially enjoy the old B&W stuff. I have learned a lot about modern video shooting from your posts which have been very helpful in my more recent pursuits.
I want you to do what makes you happy. If that means either shutting down the blog or other changes I'm just fine with that. Sure I will miss my mornings with Kirk but such is life.
Enjoy your trip to Vancouver CANADA! I look forward to hearing your stories and of course your photos.
I don't troll other photo websites as I have no interest in what is the latest or greatest. This only concerns me when and if I need something new to fulfill a current or projected need. Yours is the only blog I regularly read.
Eric
Kirk, being quite lazy, i will only say a little.
1st, BRAVO. You cover so much ground here, and although i don't get into some of it [lighting, the business, B&W photos, Leica] i still read 90% of what you write! (& for 9 yrs now)
I'll admit that I have GAS and am mostly into your gear reviews, which have been remarkably aligned w/ stuff i have owned.
So God bless you, and I hope you keep it up, but mostly wish to see you happy.
Kirk you've entertained the idea of shutting down the blog before and you always come back. I enjoy your writing and your portraits quite a bit. I don't know that you should change anything. I don't think you should be worrying too much about what you decide to write about. It should please you first. What's the old saying about coaches in sports? Those coaches who listen to the fans will soon be sitting with them, or something like that. I hope you continue but if not I totally understand. Eventually you reach a point where there isn't much more to say and enough is enough. I don't follow any other blogs and I track precious few Youtube photographers. I'm not terribly interested in gear these days. It's been good enough for quite a while. Buy what you can afford and what makes you happy. If you do decide to stop then perhaps a little notice would be nice so we can all say a proper goodbye to one another. If you are continuing then perhaps you could touch upon some current photographers who are doing interesting work and some from the past we may have temporarily forgotten. Maybe ask the readers to share some sites that are interesting.and helpful. Maybe take a hiatus. You'll enjoy Vancouver quite a bit and an adventure is always a great way to spark some creativity. I find myself still recovering mentally from the pandemic. It's affected me in ways I'm only now just realizing. Some things I used to believe in are no longer important to me. So I'm giving myself time to process everything. I thought I was fine but maybe not so much. Give yourself some time and then proceed when you are ready.
I think of you as a newspaper columnist with a certain beat. Some days I'll just glace over it, but other days I'll savor it. I love your observations about the business and your walks around Austin. I'm not a swimmer, but I usually enjoy your swimming stories. It's a mark of a good writer that they can engage you in something that you didn't know you could get interested in. And I enjoy your comments on the Leica CL as I've been shooting one longer than you have. And like all syndicated columnists, you should take some time off too. Publish golden oldies, or just put up the "gone fishing" sign. Thanks for all the words.
What do you like about the VSL blog?
The writing and your humility. You and MJ are the best writers of any photography blogs, with maybe Thom Hogan as an honorable mention. Unlike some who claim to "KNOW PHOTO!," you actually understand what you're talking about but never boast of your skills.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
I know it's your professional strength, but the lighting articles leave me cold. I'm not a pro, never do studio work, can't remember the last time I used an off-camera strobe.
What content is useful for you?
Theater and street photography. As I've said before, I've worked in local theater for decades and have seen piles of lousy theater pictures but few good images. Yours are always excellent. I envy your skill at street photography but am too reticent to do it well. Your work inspires me to think I might be able break out of my self-imposed constraints.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I'd lose one of the real high points of my browsing day!
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
No useful ideas.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
Not at all; there will always be a place for the insightful, patient, and skilled photographic observer.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
Silly question, although some of the tools have become irrelevant. I used to know a superb photographer name Dick Arnst, who used a view camera and produced beautiful platinum and palladium prints; even 30 years ago these were anachronisms and irrelevant to most of the world. I just discovered online that Dick transitioned to digital in 2000.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Mostly, but will never be able to afford most of the gear you review.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No, even though they make me feel guilty or inadequate about my lack of athletic skill/ambition.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you? Interesting but mostly not relevant-I'm a casual, mostly travel photographer, not a pro
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
Maybe a week-it will take that long to stop crying
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
That would be better than no blog at all....
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
You already post on Instagram; maybe that could continue
Where do you get your photo information?
A whole raft of photo website-many of which make me wonder why I waste the time (e.g., Fstoppers)
I read your blog all the time, for years. Have commented once or twice.
It's just hard to stay fresh at things. Especially when the field you are in isn't that dynamic in the first place. Sad to say, photography is in that category.
It's normal. I'm an Architect, been at it for 40 years, so I'm very good at it in my own little way. But 40 years is a long time. I sense you might be at a similar place, professionally speaking.
I love your blog, especially when you drag out the Sigma FP. No one else does!
My advice, based on your question, is to change the channel a little with the blog. Like George Costanza on do the opposite day. It might go places that trigger excitement and insight. You write well and expressively & have many interesting stories to tell.
I enjoy your writing and would like more off-topic topics.
Do what you feel like. Don't homogenize this thing. The near-random thoughts of a professional photographer are usually, not always, pretty interesting, but it only takes a minute to skip over the boring bits, and the good bits are really good. Look at it this way -- you write about swimming, but not about pool, which is a real strength, IMHO.
JC, I laughed so hard at your unexpected last line that I nearly had a mouthful of Stag's Leap Cab squirt out of my nose. Well played.
Probably shouldn't have a glass of wine while reading comments but....you know....time management.
Don't worry about us readers, we'll be just fine if you decide to hang it up. IMO, take three months off and if you find that you miss it, continue. If you don't, say goodbye with no regrets.
I don't read the blog for the gear reviews or technical information. I read it because I like your writing style and I enjoy how you share with us your trials and tribulations with navigating the ever changing business of photography.
I like the more casual posts best. That can be musings on gear, an image, or whatever. Write what you want, I’ll likely read it. I come here for the Kirkness of the posts, and I’m guessing that will remain.
Kirk,
1. The VSL feels more like a conversation with a friend (over coffee) than a blog.
2. There isn't much I dislike about a good conversation with an old friend.
3. There is always something to take away from your posts. Whatever you're writing about is usually informative, thought provoking, or just fun to read.
4. (See 1 and 2 above). I'd move on but the blog would be sorely missed.
5. For me, improving the blog would just mean to keep doing what you are doing, and how you do it. Improvement doesn't necessarily mean change....like a fine wine improvement comes from a slow and steady process.
6. I think you are more relevant than ever, but I think it is more about the demographics, especially for those of us that started out in the film days. I think those folks have a different perspective of you and the blog.
7. I think photography is different, not irrelevant. Different in the sense that it's a commodity, except to those that still appreciate it for what it does.
8. The gear reviews are fine. They are an insight into how and why YOU choose gear, and not click bait to purchase anything.
9. The swimming/lifestyle posts are some of my favorites. They tell us more about you, which adds to the human element of the blog.
10. I'm always fascinated how other photographers handle their jobs, assignments, etc.
11. If you were to discontinue the blog, I would just hope for enough time to prepare. I would hate to click on my link only to get a "404 Error".
12. The VSL is your blog and you can take it in any direction you choose. As long as the writing remains good and the content interesting, I would still tune in.
13. How to keep in touch, hmmm....you could start some sort of club, or group on a site. Or you could do the annual holiday letter, or you could possibly start a blog??
14. I get photo info from any number of places, especially old school publications. VSL however is the only blog I follow on a regular basis....goes great with coffee.
For me, reading blogs is mostly a form of entertainment. Internet's full of people trying to persuade me to adopt their belief system, or buy some tech gadget, but mostly I'm in it for the capybara videos.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTk688cXTsA
You're welcome.
The charms of coffee are mostly lost on me, but when I look around me, I am surrounded by coffee lovers; it seems to be one area where a lot of people are seeking something more than mere sustenance.
Lighting and light modifiers are somewhat interesting to me, because it's one area where I feel like I have lots of room to grow. Might be fun to see what your thinking is like regarding an essential kit of lights and modifiers, to be periodically updated as new toys replace older ones. I am kind of hazy as to where your latest LEDs fit into the scheme of things, as opposed to Godox strobes and so on: How do you decide what to use on a given day?
Cameras and lenses, somewhat less interesting: I feel like I hit the jackpot long ago as far as those are concerned, though I look forward to the Sony A7R8, whatever it may be.
I imagine that you got a lot of stories of individuals who needed a lot of help in order to photograph like their idealized selves, pity that a public blog isn't the best place for those!
Will there ever be another Studio Dog?
Jeff in Colorado
I like that the blog is well written. I also identify with a working photographer who also does a lot of personal work. I dislike the fact that because the blog author has to work for a living there is not always a new entry when I log in.
The content most useful to me is is a look at the thoughts of both an enthusiastic and accomplished photographer in thet it occasionally starts me thinking.
As I start my day with my email, the New York Times and this blog along with several others - ceasing the blog would change the way I start the day.
The best way to improve the blog is to keep doing it and continue to get better at it.
I don’t think the blog is irrelevant. I don’t thinkphotography is irrelevant. I do think the internet has increased the volume of the pictures we see and lowered the standard of what we consider a good photograph.
If a gear review provides me useful information, I Iike it. Obviously, there are a lot of different kinds of gear reviews.
I used to be a swimmer, even a life guard for a short while; so I accept the homage to the water.
How Kirk handles jobs, especially portraiture, is a good reminder of how to work.
I don’t want any notice if the blog is discontinued.
I get information from the internet, books, the exceptional camera store I shop at and other photographers. A lot of information come from taking pictures.
Kirk, I have said this here before, I find your blog is like getting a letter from a long-time friend and hearing how you and your family are doing. The only thing that I dislike is you make me think that I need a Leica. I don't, but I still just want one. I am currently in France documenting sites with my very lightweight travel kit, a GX8, it's 14-140 and 7-14, with a Rx100ii for the pocket. They do what I need. My G9 and a7Rii kits stayed home. If you stopped blogging I would miss hearing how you are doing plus which new camera or lens now has your attention. I look forward to seeing your upcoming travel photos.
I enjoy your narrative about life as a pro photog in Austin. Not much I don't like, but pretty much ignore stuff very specific to Leica, though why you use Leica is of interest. I study the lighting and style of your portraits, though I don't photograph people much these days for reasons you have mentioned. Some of the equipment stuff is useful also. Would miss the blog, but things change. Don't see much need for change to VSL, but then ideas for creative blog/internet content aren't really my thing. I generally enjoy the lifestyle stuff, I just skim what is not of interest. I like the articles about your work. Not of direct use, but interesting. One or more closing posts would be nice rather than just disappearing. I would miss the narrative if it was just images and captions. Don't know what to say about the keeping in touch part, maybe some comments on Mike Johnston's blog? I get info from some equipment specific forms, but generally various blogs, web pages, YT videos, and podcasts people like yourself have referenced. DPR doesn't seem of much interest to me these days.
Oh Boy a lot to think about
What do you like about the VSL blog?
What's going on in your part of the world. How you deal with business and the equipment.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
A little wordy for me, but still a good read.
What content is useful for you?
The way you justify your purchases, although it hasn't worked for me. It makes me think. There are still good people in the world.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
Yes and No. I'd miss company. I mean, I get up, brush my teeth get my coffee look at how my stocks are crashing, then wonder what's going on in Texas and if Kirk Tuck has been arrested yet. I mean, a senior with a camera taking photos. Hats, I wouldn't get to see the fashion statement. :) My Dr. says I have to wear a hat now.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Cut down on information. Less is better, more images from your walks.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
No. I think it has become more relevant.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
Yes, and No. There are factors in our society that would like to see photography go away. Although it seems everyone is a cellphone photographer now days, which I believed has created damage to working true photographers. This is why I'm returning to film more and more. I even put my darkroom back together.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Ya, what's not to like.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No not at all!!! I love to swim, but where I live now that's going to happen. I love the lifestyle. Even though we live in different areas I see we have a lot in common. You swim, I run and bike I like to see how your doing, what your doing.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Yes, I do not have jobs anymore, wish I did. So I like to see/watch what your up to and how you work your assignments.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
As much as you wish. A year or two? :) A Happy Trails to all.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
That works. Maybe people could add image and we could discuss what we like and dislike about each image.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
Vero? email, text??? Group field trip?
Where do you get your photo information?
From the real life photographer, here. The Leica Gallery, Leica forum, Sigma forum, friends.
You have to do what is best for you before it's to late.
In a side note a friend of mine Seng Merrill wife of Dick Merrill one of the people who developed the Foveon sensor just passed in August 2021 (just found out 3 days ago). Seng was laid to rest next to Dick (Dick passed in 2008) in Vermont where Dick's family was from. Seng was quite an excellent photographer in her own right. When you have a friend the same age as you, (71) pass away it makes one think about what's important........it's not gear, it's not a patients that won't listen to you or a business contract. It's about getting that one image that is true and honest, the image you'll be remembered for. There is other things like family, friends, and more as you are well aware of.
Seng and Dick didn't get enough time together. Not the time they deserved. Seng was devastated when Dick passed from cancer in 2008.
I'm back shooting my Foveon's before Sigma bought Foveon and after. I have ever camera Dick issued me and they still work fine.
I'm sure you'll come to your decision when your ready.
Good luck
Roger
Oregon
What do you like about the VSL blog? Your writing, your views, understanding how you work with flash and continuous light.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog? I'm not particularly interested in video, but I just skip what I'm not interested in.
What content is useful for you? Almost all of it. You are a gifted writer, with well informed opinions and a positive but realistic outlook on life that I enjoy reading. Your writings on how you approach (and light) portraits, along with your portrait images does my soul good.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way? Yes. Your blog is the first one I check and read every day. I was quite disappointed (but understood) when you last considered ending it. I wish I could support you financially in some small way although I clearly read that you're not maintaining it for that reason.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part? Just keep writing when it suits you. Even if you cut back the frequency of your posts, I'll appreciate whatever you choose to post.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant? Absolutely NOT.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant? No, but I have never felt that reading your blog was for the purpose of starting or maintaining a career as a photographer.
Do you like the gear reviews? I really enjoy when you share how you approach a new piece of gear because you speak of your personal experience and not the garbage I can get at dprev_ew.com or on YouTube.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.? Oh, I suppose it reminds me that I haven't made a lot of healthy choices regarding my exercise and lifestyle, but then again, maybe it's a good reminder to get out of my chair and go walking and taking photos.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you? Incredibly so. I've learned more from you than any other source on the web.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog? It's your blog and that's up to you. I don't know that "notice" per se will make much of a difference. I wish you well regardless of the blog.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions? Whatever you want to do is up to you - please continue sharing your portrait work.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog? That's up to you. I've been mostly a lurker, but I do look forward to your blog posts and writing.
Where do you get your photo information? I've turned to some YouTube channels that focus on what the content provider is passionate about in regards to what they like to shoot (seascapes, portraits, some film enthusiasts, people who share their thoughts and feelings about what they try to acheive in their photography).
Frankly, I picked up a couple of Sony SLT-A77 DSLRs in 2011-2012 when you were using them, and I fully accept that my photography is only limited by my skills (or lack thereof) and I'd be a fool to go buy more new equipment. I use a Panasonic FZ-1000 mk 1 as my carry around, and a Nikon P950 superzoom for occasional bird photography.
I don't need any more damn equipment, and I couldn't care less what Canon/Nikon/Sony/Panasonic is coming out with anymore. I need to save my retirement dollars for supplementing all the damned donut holes (gaping holes) in Medicare coverage. You could still outshine anything I do using your Kodak DSLR from 20 years ago vs. me with my best equipment.
I wish you the best, but do what makes you happy.
Best,
Craig C. in Minneapolis
I visit and read your blog because I like your style and it is interesting to get a glimps of someone elses life and views. Have been visiting since I found you blog when you were trying out the Nikon V1 and have kept reading ever since. It is the mix of different things that you write about that makes the blog interesting.
I read your blog every day so yes, I would miss it if it were gone. I really enjoy your work stories about lighting setups and the business end of things. The swimming and personal stuff is also interesting since at this point you seem like a distant friend whom I will never get to meet but like hearing about. I have mentioned it before and I think that you have taken offense, but since you asked I will say again, I think that your photos of the side of buildings with the sky in the frame are kind of beyond blah..Not really sure what that is about but you apparently love to do it since it is always part of your photos. Contrarily any of your people photos and of course your portrait work is great. Keep doing what you are doing s far as I am concerned but I can understand the need to change things up from time to time.
I came to this blog because I struggled with accepting digital. For 30 years I used a Canon F1 and a Mamiya 6x6. I tried for a year to scan negatives and slides then, on the basis of your blog, I bought an Olympus EPl camera that I got along with for a number of years, then bought a Fuji S5 pro (which I should never have sold). And am now interested in smaller cameras with no video facility but have a Fuji XT that I use with my old FD lenses. I say all of this because you have greatly helped me on my journey. So your gear reviews are helpful as they are a working photographer's views and are about the things that really matter when you are on the street with the new purchase. And often its not about the sensor but the positioning of controls, weight, strap locks etc. My biggest issue about digital was getting my head around how to produce good prints. You have helped me a lot with this and lighting. If you want to improve the blog for me, show me some landscapes around Austin. I can't swim, so I skip those sections! I love your street photos and portraits.You give us a standard to aim for. You provide a human perspective on art, which is so often missing. You are as far removed from DPreview as can be - that's a good thing BTW. I dont agree with your political statements, especially about covid restrictions, but its your blog and you can say what you please. I also now wear a hat because of you - so you are doing something right!
Hi Kirk,
so much feedback and long constructive comments ! Don’t have many words to add. I simply like this blog as it is. Have been reading it for some years now almost daily. Hope you will continue. Regards and best wishes,
Helmut the Austrian.
A a long-time reader, I enjoy the blog as it is, but you need to enjoy publishing it. Do what you need to do to keep it interesting and worthwhile to you. I'm sure I will still enjoy it.
What do you like about the VSL blog?
Honest, fluent writing | Insightful and often serendipitous reflections and observations. | Gear usage and assessment. | Humour and self-deprecation. | Sharing experiences, enthusiasm and concerns for this life, art and its paraphernalia. | The ‘comments’ from other readers.
What do you dislike about the VSL blog?
No ‘dislikes’. Perhaps a little more focus at times wouldn’t go amiss.
Would ceasing the blog affect you in any way?
I would miss the friendly, rational voice and feeling of community.
What would be the best way to improve the blog without entailing even a tiny shred of more work on my part?
Sometimes shorter and more focussed posts. Perhaps think about stepping back to think about what the main thread of what you want to say is and then stick to that path.
Do you think the changing nature of photography has made the blog and its content worker irrelevant?
No. More than ever we need honest content, rational thinking, and ‘community space’.
Do you think photography has become irrelevant?
No. Good, honest photography is as relevant as ever. However, I think photographers are less relevant and society's trust of imagery is a growing issue.
Do you like the gear reviews?
Yes. I think many of us have shared a similar journey and experience with different formats. And knowing that this is a work in progress, that we never stop learning, makes us curious. I also like the human side of how you approach your purchase decisions and your honesty about gear that doesn’t meet expectations.
Do you really hate the posts about swimming/lifestyle/etc.?
No. As others have said, they are your context and help to explain your diligence to the craft and your blog.
Are articles about how Kirk handles jobs/projects/assignments still useful to you?
Yes - always good to read about how you plan to meet the needs of a job or vacation and how things worked out.
How much notice would you like to get if the executive decision is made to discontinue this blog?
It's your call... I don't need any notice.
How would you feel about a new blog that contains only new images and relevant captions?
That sounds more like a website gallery. I think that without a written companion post (or very recently related post), images - even well captioned ones - would lack context, personality and meaning. Taken together your writing and images are synergistic.
What would be the best way to keep in touch if a decision was made to discontinue the blog?
A newsletter, as others have suggested, would be better than nothing. However, my motivation to open and read a newsletter wouldn’t be the same … it would probably feel a bit disconnected and more of a chore.
Where do you get your photo information?
Your blog; magazines (Professional Photographer, B+W Photographer); countless books; You Tube (no allegiances, gear and technique searches); monthly face to face meetings of a group of local photographers; web retailers (gear specs, prices)
Thank you for the blog Kirk and best wishes for wherever this takes you.
I would read you in a box
I would read you with a fox.
I would read you in the house.
I would read you with a mouse.
I would read here or there.
I would read you anywhere.
A Seuss day!
I went from Sony A77 to Pana GH4 to Fuji XH-1 to Pana GH5ii because of your reviews (I still have all of them). Swimming is great. Exercise is great. Getting old is tolerable. Time for another Tulip? Yes!
Hi Kirk
I've been reading your blog daily for years - which I wouldn't do if I didn't really enjoy it, right? Just a couple of reasons why: Your perspective on foto technology, on photographing itself, on the photography business, on your own business, your attitude towards life, family, and society, your way of writing, your humor a.s.o. In other words, I would miss your blog a lot.
I can relate to the feeling that you don't want to constantly regurgitate - as for me, I can say you have never bored me at all, maybe because the posted subjects may often be similar in one way or another, but then do differ due to the in every respect drastically changing environment. In other words, I don't need a change in your subjects.
A completely personal reason for my interest - besides photography - is that your blog represents a view into a (now totally different) country I left 56 years ago after having spent 10 childhood years in the states. A time that is connected with fond memories and that had a major influence in my life since then. In other words, I would very miss this link/window very much.
I hesitate to ask you to continue since I know how much time and effort you have to invest to keep this blog going, but (see above)....
In any case, thank you
erka
Kirk, I'll answer your questions without reading the preceding comments (because then I'll just feel like they provided the answer already and I won't bother).
As long time readers (and I have been visiting since Mike introduced you) we get as attached to you as a person as you get attached to writing the blog. I started reading because, at the time, you were using Canon cameras and I was/am using Canon cameras. I had just purchased a 60D and there you were, using a 60D on some of your jobs, and waxing lyrically about older Canon DSLRs and the way they rendered your subjects. It was fun, and motivational, and allowed me to keep reminding myself, which is a life-long process, that it was not my camera brand that was at fault for any poor performance I might perceive. But I never earned my living from photography, nor did I use artificial light for the majority of my shooting.
You moved on from Canon gear, but I kept reading. It was, in a way, a blessing that you kept changing gear as often as you did. You always wrote positively about the new cameras you purchased. The quality of your photography stayed at the same level (aside from higher resolution and better low light noise control) as you progressed through iterations of Sony, Nikon, Fuji, Panasonic, and Leica cameras. Again, it was not the camera brand, but the optimal use of lenses, lighting, and technique that mattered. Over the course of more than 10 years of following you this was an important lesson to keep in the back of my mind.
Your blog and your writing, even when you are prickly about something, is an influence like the influence of an experienced friend, if you will. And even the off-topic writing about swimming, or walking, or medical check-ups, is an influence in getting at least some of your readers off their butts and moving. In the end, of course, it is your readers that have to connect with your writing and with you, and get something out of it. Some do and they are the ones that keep coming back. Some don't and they might leave nasty comments, or simply not come back. For those readers who make the connection your blog serves not only an educational and inspirational purpose, it also opens a window into your life. From that perspective every new post is an update on how you and your family are doing, as well as how the city is doing. As long as you keep writing, looking forward to the next day, the next walk with a camera, job challenge, road trip, hike, swim, you'll continue to keep that audience. We enjoy the photos and the opinions.
But at the same time, you should not feel compelled to keep writing for someone else's sake. If you are getting bored with it and would rather devote your energy to other things then you know what you need/want to do. Friendships inevitably end for a variety of reasons. People move on and find new adventures in life. Whether you keep the blog running for when your readers want to remember something you said, or you want to shut it down, is up to you.
Thanks to everyone who replied and took time to help me out with good info!
I think it's safe to cap the flow of comments for this post here.
Loved learned what works and what doesn't. I'll apply the info diligently.
Still enjoy blogging. Thanks for the new energy.
New comments are not allowed.