I was playing around with this image and remembered that I used a Pentax 120 mm Macro lens on a 6x4.5 cm negative. I like the lighting and tonality of the image but I'm not at all happy with the way that lens, used too close in, accentuates Rene's nose and draws out her chin and mouth. While it's entirely personal taste, every time I get too close (closer than 6 feet?) with a lens I find myself disturbed by the way faces are rendered. This image would have worked better for me if I'd used a longer focal length or stepped back a few feet and then cropped in during post processing.
This is, I think, totally independent of format. I am equally uncomfortable using a 50mm lens on an APS-C camera if I step across that imaginary line at six feet. Too much foreshortening. Given the focal length equivalents on cell phones we tend to see a lot of foreshortened social media images and eventually (sadly) the general population will come to regard that look as normal and appropriate.
Again, everyone's taste is different but for my satisfaction the longer the focal length (up to a point) the more flattering the image for normal faces. My all time favorite film combination was the Zeiss 180mm f4.0 on a 6x6cm Hasselblad. Currently, when shooting portraits with a full frame Sony camera and their wildly good 70-200mm f2.8 G lens I find myself constantly ending up at about 120mm on the zoom ring. And when I shoot in m4:3rds I like a 50mm, really like the 60mm and love the 70mm focal length. Images done with that optic are generally done from further away from my subjects and the final result is a bit of flattening which de-emphasizes the nose and, with good posing, can also make chins look more normal. The longer focal lengths also allow me more control over depth of field and finally, with the best of the older lenses, even in smaller formats the bokeh (or the quality of the blur produced) can be very calm and lovely.
Why would I show a photo I find fault with? So we can talk about the possibilities.
It's good to get close. There's a line you probably shouldn't cross. Yikes, foreshortening.
6 comments:
I LOVE all your Renée portraits, and this one is especially beautiful !!! By the way regarding the previous post I'm also a Snapseed user, but generally I stay away from Vintage and Grunge, so not too concerned with the issue... A little Drama, Center Focus and B&W are my most used filters, I find the quick and dirty monochrome conversions crazy good.
Did you perhaps mean 6x4.5 cm, rather than inch?
Other than that, I agree with you on portrait focal length. I think working distance is the critical factor and about 5 to 6 feet works for me. Many years ago someone told me to do portraits at a conversational distance -- around 5 feet for a formal look, a bit closer for a more personal feel -- then choose the focal length for the crop you want.
I find 135mm on full frame and 70mm on 4/3 give me about the crop I like at a comfortable distance.
Gato, thanks for catching the "inch" error. I've corrected it on the post. Happy New Year!
Claire, Thank you!
Although I fully agree with your focal length preferences for portraits, I think this particular portrait of Ms. Zellweger is unusually appealing and works better than it would have with a longer lens. In fact, I find it about the most appealing portrait I have ever seen of her.
The portrait is wonderful! However, I agree with you 100%. It took me a while to see the distortion inherent when using a "normal" lens too close.
I agree with the others - there is something appealing about this photo. I understand your concern about how too short a focal length can cause distortion of some facial features. I'm not sure that's a real problem here. But is there a point where the focal length becomes too long? The flattening effect is too much, or there is too much distance between you and subject. I once read fashion photographers often did outdoor shoots using 300+mm lenses. How would one communicate easily with a model using one of those?
Post a Comment
We Moderate Comments, Yours might not appear right after you hit return. Be patient; I'm usually pretty quick on getting comments up there. Try not to hit return again and again.... If you disagree with something I've written please do so civilly. Be nice or see your comments fly into the void. Anonymous posters are not given special privileges or dispensation. If technology alone requires you to be anonymous your comments will likely pass through moderation if you "sign" them. A new note: Don't tell me how to write or how to blog! I can't make you comment but I don't want to wade through spam!
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.